Jonathan Groff
Holden Ford - 19 episoder

Holt McCallany
Bill Tench - 19 episoder

Anna Torv
Wendy Carr - 19 episoder

Sonny Valicenti
ADT Serviceman - 15 episoder

Stacey Roca
Nancy Tench - 12 episoder

Cotter Smith
Unit Chief Shepard - 11 episoder

Hannah Gross
Debbie Mitford - 10 episoder

Joe Tuttle
Gregg Smith - 10 episoder

Zachary Scott Ross
Brian Tench - 10 episoder

Lauren Glazier
Kay Manz - 8 episoder

Albert Jones
Jim Barney - 8 episoder

Michael Cerveris
Assistant Director Gunn - 6 episoder

June Carryl
Camille Bell - 5 episoder

Dohn Norwood
Commissioner Lee Brown - 5 episoder

Gareth Williams
Chief Redding - 5 episoder

Cameron Britton
Edmund Kemper - 4 episoder

Nate Corddry
Detective Art Spencer - 4 episoder

Sierra Aylina McClain
Tanya Clifton - 4 episoder

Siovhan Christensen
Beverly Belt - 4 episoder

Alex Morf
Detective Ocasek - 3 episoder

Katherine Banks
Joanne - 2 episoder

Regi Davis
Mayor Jackson - 3 episoder

Christopher Livingstone
Wayne Williams - 3 episoder

Erik Jensen
Dr. Moritz - 3 episoder

Christopher Grove
AD Wyman - 3 episoder

Blythe Howard
News Anchor #1 - 3 episoder

Bryan McClure
Alex Clarke - 3 episoder

Darrin Giossi
Recruit - 3 episoder

Crystal Lee Brown
Willie Mae Mathis - 3 episoder

Peter Murnik
Detective Carver - 2 episoder

Joseph Cross
Benjamin Barnwright - 2 episoder

Jesse C. Boyd
Frank Janderman - 2 episoder

Happy Anderson
Jerry Brudos - 2 episoder

Marc Kudisch
Roger Wade - 2 episoder

Duke Lafoon
Detective Chambers - 2 episoder

Michael Park
Peter Dean - 2 episoder

George R. Sheffey
John Boylen - 2 episoder

Patrick Jordan
Prison Employee - 1 episoder

Don O. Knowlton
Father Monaghan - 2 episoder

Drew Seltzer
Dale Harmon - 2 episoder