Helen Mirren
Cara Dutton - 15 episoder

Harrison Ford
Jacob Dutton - 15 episoder

Brandon Sklenar
Spencer Dutton - 15 episoder

Julia Schlaepfer
Alexandra 'Alex' of Sussex - 15 episoder

Jerome Flynn
Banner Creighton - 15 episoder

Darren Mann
Jack Dutton - 15 episoder

Isabel May
Elsa Dutton (Narrator) (voice) - 15 episoder

Brian Geraghty
Zane Davis - 15 episoder

Aminah Nieves
Teonna Rainwater - 15 episoder

Michelle Randolph
Elizabeth Strafford - 15 episoder

Tahkyah Brings Plenty
Jesse Plenty clouds - 15 episoder

Caleb Martin
Dennis - 13 episoder

Timothy Dalton
Donald Whitfield - 11 episoder

Robert Patrick
Sheriff McDowell - 11 episoder

Sebastian Roché
Father Renaud - 10 episoder

Michael Spears
Runs His Horse - 10 episoder

Brian Konowal
Clyde - 6 episoder

Jamie McShane
Marshal Kent - 9 episoder

Madison Rogers
Lindy - 7 episoder

Mark Daneri
Dr. Steven Miller - 3 episoder

Jeremy Gauna
Pete Plenty Clouds - 6 episoder

Joy Osmanski
Alice Davis - 5 episoder

Marley Shelton
Emma Dutton - 5 episoder

Ross Crain
US Marshal Thomas - 3 episoder

Henry Emde
Matthew Davis - 5 episoder

Remy Holt
Madelyne Davis - 4 episoder

Colt Brown
Alec - 3 episoder

Jennifer Ehle
Sister Mary - 4 episoder

Leenah Robinson
Baapuxti - 4 episoder

Jo Ellen Pellman
Jennifer - 4 episoder

Sarah Randall Hunt
Ellie Creighton - 4 episoder

Michael Greyeyes
Hank - 4 episoder

Dakota Ogden
Carl - 3 episoder

Cailyn Rice
Christy - 4 episoder

Jennifer Carpenter
US Marshal Mamie Fossett - 4 episoder

James Badge Dale
John Dutton, Sr. - 3 episoder

Kerry O'Malley
Sister Alice - 3 episoder

Tim DeKay
Bob Strafford - 3 episoder

Bruce Davison
Arthur - 3 episoder

Amelia Rico
Issaxche - 3 episoder